Why did all the bots underestimate this Clearlake home's value?

This home at  3158 14th St in Clearlake is a 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom single-family home that was built in 2006. It has a total square footage of 1,200 square feet. The home was last sold in December 2022 for $122,000. Some of the features of the home include a large living room, a spacious kitchen, along with a large backyard that includes a deck and a pool. It also has a two-car garage. 


What do the bots think about this property's value? Here are screenshots of what we found:

Every bot underestimated the value of this property.


Redfin was close, but on average the bots underestimated by over $21,000.


What was the expert's list price? Timothy Toye and Associates listed this property for $275,000 in June of 2023. 


Let's see how the expert's price compares with each of the bot estimates:

Expert Price vs Bot Estimates for 3158 14 St, Clearlake
3158 14th St, Clearlak, Loss Or Gain Compared to Expert List Price

Remax /Smartzip, Bank of America and Rocket were way off, as much as $55,000 under the expert's list price.


Why are all the bots underestimating this home's value?


We think it's a local phenomena. In general, property values have been challenged of late, from rising interest rates. The bots just indiscriminately assumed this pressure would apply here.


This is why you cannot trust bots. A local real estate expert knows what homes are selling for, and prices accordingly.


In this case, we believe the expert knew that while there is negative pressure from rising interest rates, it will not affect this property in this particular area. It will be really interesting to see what this home ends up selling for!


Thinking about selling? Don't trust bots to estimate your home's value. Request a property value report from Damon Schoeffler, your Lake County expert. It's free and without obligation.

Get Free Report
June 14, 2026
Can I Trust the ‘Zestimate’ for My Home on Zillow? | New York Times Real Estate Q&A Pretty remarkable statement in the middle of this short article: A Sotheby's agent is quoted as saying, "He has never heard of a tax assessor relying on a Zestimate." Don't rely on algorithmic valuations for your property's value. These estimates are interesting, but anything but the final word. Read the paywalled article on NYTimes.com >
3 reasons online home value estimates fail
April 13, 2026
Why Your Zillow Estimate is Wrong | What Your Home is Actually Worth | Pauly Campanaro Discover the 3 reasons online home value estimates fail: they can't account for condition (your $40K kitchen remodel), they lag behind the market (using 60-90 day old data), and they don't know your competition (what's hitting the market this week). Learn why pricing right matters: homes priced correctly sell 19 days faster and for 3.8% more ($15K+ on a $400K home). Excerpted from this video posted by Pauly Campanaro:
Screenshot of a Twitter post by Ryan Lundquist, discussing a property's Zestimate history and price changes.
September 15, 2023
@SacAppraiser | Ryan Lundquist Zestimate history. This property in Roseville listed at $349K, and the Zestimate matched the list price at $349K despite comps being above $600K. After 11 days the price went to $699K (sold $638K). Today's Zestimate shows no history of $349K. Maybe a brief Zestimate gets erased?
Show More